Monday, January 5, 2009

Blogging for Lesbian Health Day


Today's article is part of "Blog for Lesbian Health Day," which was started by organizers of the National Lesbian Health Summit 2009. Back in December, I was approached by an organizer and asked to write about issues that affect me in all or some of those roles within the overall health-care experience. More specifically, I was asked about my personal health-care experiences as a lesbian, and also what issues I am concerned about for myself and community.

So, without further ado, here are my individual thoughts and experiences. As a patient and a nurse. And always, as a lesbian:

The first and most obvious issue of concern regarding lesbian health revolves around lesbian sexual health. A term within the (LBT-knowledgeable) health-care community is "lesbian neglect." Lesbian neglect refers to the fact that many lesbians fail to get Pap smears, do not get them regularily, and/or do not think they need to get them.

Dr. Jeanne Marrazzo of the University of Washington has published several reports on the sexual health of sexual minority women. In one, she discusses barriers to infectious disease care among lesbians. For one, there is relatively little data on STIs, Pap smear screening, and cervical dysplasia among lesbians, all of which are needed to make clinical guidelines for lesbians. Secondly, health-care providers and lay-people commonly assume that a.) sex between women confers virtually no risk, or b.) it is at the bottom of a hierarchy of higher-risk behaviors. However, transmission of HPV, syphilis, and HIV between women have been reported. All of that being said, it is important to reiterate that virtually no data exists of the relative risk of STD transmission in same-gender sex among women.

Of the data that exists, it does show that lesbian neglect is a fair portrayal in regards to lesbians and Pap smears. In the Marrazzo articled previously mentioned, 95% (236) of lesbians in one study believed they should receive Pap smears annually or every 2 years after normal results, yet 36% (90) provided a reason for not having done so. The most commonly cited reasons were "lack of health insurance, adverse experience at prior Pap smear screening, and a belief they did not need it because they were not sexually active with men."

Sadly, 9 of the women reported being told by their health-care provider that they did not need a Pap smear since they did not have sex with men. As an FYI, Marraazzo and other LBT-knowledgeable health-care providers recommend that lesbians follow the same cervical cancer screening guidelines as all women.

Per the American Cancer Society that means that women should begin getting a Pap within 3 years of their first sexual activity, and no later than age 21 for women sexually active after the age of 18. For all of the recommendations, please go here.

Pap smears and lesbian neglect hit close to home for me. I received my first one at the tender age of 26, when I finally had health insurance...and, when I got over my case of lesbian neglect. It was quick and relatively painless. My doctor had been practicing for 30 years or so, and I didn't feel uncomfortable. She also did a sexual history, inquired about the gender of my sexual partners, and provided non-judgmental care. She was nice. But she wasn't LBT knowledgeable. At the end of my visit, she came back to my exam room and told me that since I didn't sleep with men, I didn't need another Pap, ever.

Needless to say, even though she was nice and the procedure was painless, I never went back to her. Everyone deserves culturally competent care, and sexual orientation should always be a part of that competence and knowledge base.

That is my one major advice to lesbians (and any sexual minority): You have the right to be treated compassionately, non-judgmentally, and competently. You also should always be given the change to disclose your orientation or identity in a non-awkward manner. A health-care provider should never just assume you are heterosexual without first asking you who your partners are.

Which brings me to my other point, the one major issue I would LOVE to see incorporated into nursing schools and med schools is sexual minority health.

I graduated from nursing school within the past 5 years, so I know that the lack of education on sexual minorities we received is not a matter of time-appropriateness.

The one time in my nursing school program that lesbian health was even mentioned was when my professor stated, "Lesbian and bisexual women will have...other... concerns, but we aren't going to discuss those today" before venturing to the next nursing school topic du jour. (because we ALL need yet another lecture on HIPPA or standard precautions)

I was forced with a milli-second decision on whether I was going to risk outing myself (by virtue of guilt-by-association) to a class that considered it somewhat okay to make fun of gays and lesbians occasionally, or sit there and silently wonder to myself just what these "other" issues unique to lesbians were.

In retrospect, and having since come out to my nursing school and classmates, I should have raised my hand and demanded a further explanation. A discussion, at the very least. But that didn't happen at the time. And thus, none of my classmates nor I ever received education on lesbian health.

Instead, I chose to go into the field of LGBT healthcare following graduation from nursing school. I take part in any related continuing education courses offered by organizations in my area. However, my education on LGBT healthcare is taught to me, 9 out of 10 times, by my colleagues and patients. Sometimes it feels like we are making it up as we go. But usually there is someone more senior, more knowledgeable, and with more experience we can go to. I am thankful that the tide seems to be turning in regards to lesbian health awareness.

There are, of course, other health issues that occur more often in lesbians (like smoking, depression, obesity, etc.) that I believe definitely need more attention. Our little community is, I believe, doing a decent job of addressing these issues.

And thanks to the groundbreaking work of people like Dr. Marrazzo and others who study sexual minority women, and the National Lesbian Health Summit, we can all look forward to a day in the near future when it is no longer taken for granted that all women are either heterosexual or have no health issues.

To a day that lesbian health is deemed a worthy topic in nursing and medical schools.

And most importantly, to a day that lesbians are included in national guidelines relating to "women's health" and not simply overlooked as unimportant or (mistakenly) without risk.

After all, we are women, too.



Reference

Marrazzo JM. Barriers to infectious disease care among lesbians. Emerg Infect Dis [serial on the Internet]. 2004 Nov [retrieved on 1/5/09]. Available from http://www.cdc.gov/ncidod/EID/vol10no11/04-0467.htm

15 comments:

Anonymous said...

Jane,

Thank you for writing this. As someone who works in the trenches of lesbian health day in and day out, it becomes easy to feel like I am the only one thinking about it. It is good to hear other lesbians talk about their experiences, especially, when there is still so much work to be done.

The fact is, one woman going down on another, does not inherently put you at a higher risk for any health conditions. While lesbians around the world can let out a collective sigh of relief, the reality is almost even worse. We are impacted differently, we are at great health risks for some conditions, yet, it is not because we are inherently different, but rather, because of cultural differences, invisibility, discrimination, lack of information of both the consumer as well as the provider.
These are fixable! Yet, lesbians have been around since women have been, and they have not been fixed yet. Not fully anyway. There are still lesbians who get cervical cancer because they don't get paps, because they were told they didn't have to since they don't sleep with men. There are still dykes who do not get breast/chest exams because they do not know of a provider who feels comfortable touching their masculine body. There are still queers who smoke too much, drink too much, and live with depression because they are not presented with knowlegeable, factual, affirming messages and supportive services that are relevent to them.

A lot of work has been done, but there is still so much more that needs to happen.

Thank you for coming out and thank you for providing culturally competent care to other lesbians.

I long for the day when a lesbian woman does not feel that she has to see a lesbian provider. Until that day comes, I am thankful for people like you.

Fannie Wolfe said...

Great article Jane!

Antigone said:

"We are impacted differently, we are at great health risks for some conditions, yet, it is not because we are inherently different, but rather, because of cultural differences, invisibility, discrimination, lack of information of both the consumer as well as the provider."

I think that's always really important to emphasize. I've seen my share of ignorant anti-gays cite lesbian health differences as "proof" that we are inherently different (ie- immoral) than heterosexuals.

Jane Know said...

Fannie,
I was going to mention the various anti-lesbian articles I've seen from the propaganda sites, but I didn't want to ruin that article by including hatred and purposeful lies about lesbians. Contrary to what many medical providers and lesbians themselves believe about having less risk, some people like to claim that lesbians have disproportionately higher rates of STDs and HIV than heterosexual women (in order to advance their own anti-LGBT agendas). The lies and purposeful misinterpretation of data (like using data from "bisexual" and/or IV drug-using sex workers to "prove" that women who have sex with women have higher HIV rates than women who only sleep with men, for example).

Obviously, bisexual or even lesbian identified sex workers are not representative of most lesbians. But I think most people know this.

ProstateCancer said...

Thanks for mentioning Lesbian Health Day. I thought you might be interested to know our community has a national nonprofit for LGBT cancer survivors called, Out With Cancer. It has two websites, http://www.lgbtcancer.com and http://www.outwithcancer.com Please email me at darryl@outwithcancer.com if you would like more information.

Negocio Inversiones said...

I just want to emphasize the good work on this blog, has excellent views and a clear vision of what you are looking for.

tom said...

Purchase Viagra

Viagra

Ultram

Buy Viagra

Viagra

Viagra

Buy Viagra online

Cheap Viagra

Buy Viagra

Generic Viagra

Viagra Online

Buy Viagra Online

Buy Viagra Online

Buy Viagra

buy viagra no prescription

buy viagra no prescription

buy viagra without prescription

buy viagra without prescription

Buy Viagra Discount Online

Buy Viagra Discount Online

Discount Viagra online

Buy Generic Viagra Online

Buy Viagra Online
Buy Viagra Online

Buy Cheap Viagra

Buy generic viagra online

Buy generic viagra online

Buy Viagra online

Viagra Discount

buy viagra no prescription

buy viagra no prescription

buy viagra no prescription

buy viagra no prescription

buy viagra Without prescription

Order Viagra

Order Viagra

Purchase Viagra

Buy Viagra No Prescription

Viagra Alternative

Viagra Alternative

Buy Viagra Online

buy viagra Without prescription

Viagra Alternative

tom said...


Buy Viagra No Prescription

Buy Viagra No Prescription

Buy Viagra No Prescription

Buy Viagra No Prescription
Buy Cialis

Buy Cialis Online

Cialis

Buy Cialis


Buy Cialis Online

Buy Cheap Cialis

Buy Cheap Cialis

Buy Cialis Online

Buy Cialis

Buy Cialis Online

Buy Cialis no prescription Online

Buy Cialis Without prescription Online

Buy Cialis Without prescription Online

Buy Cialis Online

Buy Cialis Online

Buy Cialis Online

Buy Cialis Online

Buy Cialis Online

Buy Cialis Online

Buy Cialis Online

Buy Cialis no prescription Online

Buy Cheap Cialis Online

Buy Cialis no prescription Online

Buy Cheap Cialis Online

Buy Discount Cialis Online

Buy Cialis no prescription Online

Order Cialis Online

Buy Cialis Discount Online

Order Cialis Online

Order Cialis Online

Purchase Cialis Online

Buy Cialis Without prescription Online

Buy Cialis Without prescription Online

Buy Cialis No Prescription

Buy Cialis No Prescription

Buy Cialis No Prescription

Buy Cialis No Prescription

Buy Cialis No Prescription

Buy Cialis Online

viagra prescription said...

Hello people want to express my satisfaction with this blog very creative and I really like the views of the focus very good indeed Thank you for the helpful information. I hope you keep up the good work on making your blog a success!

Anonymous said...

First off all I would like to thank you for that great post. It's very interesting to read your posts. As I can see, a lot of people here knows much about ED treatment maybe they can help me. For a long time I can't decide what is better: to buy viagra, to buy cialis or levitra? I found this online pharmacy no prescription to buy all this things, so can somebody help me to make a decision? IMHO I should buy viagra

Ücretsiz Tarot said...

"We are impacted differently, we are at great health risks for some conditions, yet, it is not because we are inherently different, but rather, because of cultural differences, invisibility, discrimination, lack of information of both the consumer as well as the provider."

Anonymous said...

I honestly trust that the know-how specified is associated to just about every person . Regards .
Locksmith West palm beach
Nashville Locksmith
Locksmith Saratoga CA
Fremont locksmith
Locksmith Fremont CA
Locksmith Fremont CA
Locksmith Fremont CA
locksmith fort worth tx
plano locksmiths
fort worth locksmiths
locksmith fort worth tx
fort worth locksmiths
locksmith miami beach fl
fort worth locksmiths
Locksmith Hialeah FL
Locksmith Mesquite
Locksmith Mesquite
Locksmith Mesquite
Locksmith Hialeah FL
Locksmith Hialeah FL
pembroke pines fl locksmith

Anonymous said...

just phenomenal,thanx for this tutorial post,i liked it very much pf changs coupons

Christian Louboutin sale said...

To be honest, I don’t know the brand of Christian Louboutin shoes before. But after knowing it, I found it rather easy to know and love the Christian Louboutin shoes since they have the signature red sole which makes you to figure out them from other brand high heels. They are so lovable since they could make you more mature and more elegant.

Usually speaking, for the lady who wears the cheap louboutin shoes for the first time would be afraid of being uncomfortable because of the high heel. But the truth comes to be that the worries are needless. The Christian Louboutin shoes are perfectly designed. So when you wear them, you won’t feel uncomfortable but even as comfortable as wearing flat shoes. There would be hidden platform in the shoes which makes your toes more comfortable to bear the weight of your body.

Someone said Christian Louboutin sale shoes have the magic to make all ladies feel more self-confident when wearing them. So why not have a try on them yourself? I am sure you would fall in love with them too. Besides, having a pair of Christian Louboutin shoes, you won’t worry about what to wear in wedding or parties.

viagra online canada said...

Really great post, Thank you for sharing This knowledge.Excellently written article, if only all bloggers offered the same level of content as you, the internet would be a much better place. Please keep it up!

mieux que le viagra said...

hey buddy,this is one of the best posts that I�ve ever seen; you may include some more ideas in the same theme. I�m still waiting for some interesting thoughts from your side in your next post.